GrammarNook.
← Confusable Words Index

shall” vs. “will

Use "will" as the standard, modern choice for future tense in virtually all contexts; reserve "shall" for formal/legal obligation, or polite first-person suggestions and questions ("shall we?").

shall

"Shall" is a modal verb historically used to express future tense, particularly with "I" and "we" in formal or traditional British English ("I shall attend the meeting"), and it's also used to express obligation, especially in legal and formal documents ("the tenant shall pay rent by the first of the month"). It comes from Old English "sceal," originally meaning "to owe" or "to be obliged," a sense still preserved in its legal and formal use today.

will

"Will" is the far more common modal verb used to express future tense in modern English across nearly all subjects and contexts ("I will call you tomorrow," "she will arrive at noon"), and it can also express willingness, intention, or determination ("I will not give up"). It comes from Old English "willan," meaning "to want or wish," and has become the standard, default way to express future tense in virtually all modern English dialects.

The real distinction

The traditional rule taught in older grammar books held that "shall" should be used with first-person subjects ("I shall," "we shall") to express simple future tense, while "will" should be used with second- and third-person subjects ("you will," "they will") for the same purpose — and reversing the pattern (using "will" with "I" or "shall" with "you") was traditionally said to convey strong determination or command instead of simple prediction. In practice, this elaborate rule has almost entirely disappeared from everyday American and increasingly British English, where "will" has become the default choice for future tense regardless of subject, and "shall" now survives mainly in a few specialized contexts: formal or legalistic writing ("the parties shall comply with all terms"), polite suggestions and questions ("shall we begin?", "shall I open a window?"), and certain fixed, formal, or ceremonial expressions. Modern usage guides largely treat the old person-based "shall/will" distinction as an outdated, largely irrelevant rule that most contemporary writers can safely ignore, since "will" is now universally understood and accepted for expressing future tense in virtually every context, while "shall" is reserved for its narrower, more formal or legal function of expressing obligation or for polite first-person questions and suggestions.

Examples with “shall

Examples with “will

Memory trick

Think of "shall" as belonging to formal contracts and polite offers — imagine a lawyer or a butler using it ("the parties shall," "shall I take your coat?"). "Will" is the everyday, all-purpose word for future tense that everyone uses constantly, with none of the old-fashioned formality attached. A final test: if the sentence sounds like it belongs in a legal contract or a very formal invitation, "shall" may fit; for virtually everything else, modern English defaults to "will."

Related confusions

All confusable words